Shrine of Banat al-Hasan al-Muthanna, Fatimah and Ruqayyah, Peace Be Upon Them
IRQ-0164
Introduction
The shrine of Banat al-Hasan al-Muthanna, Fatimah and Ruqayyah, Peace Be Upon Them, in the Al-Muhannawiya rural area of Saddat al-Hindiya in Babil is a known local Hasani-attributed shrine. Local tradition connects it with Fatimah and Ruqayyah, daughters of al-Hasan al-Muthanna, and some popular references also preserve names such as Khadra and Saada.
Al-Hasan al-Muthanna ibn Imam al-Hasan al-Mujtaba, Peace Be Upon Him, is an important figure in Hasani genealogy. His marriage to Fatimah bint Imam al-Husayn, Peace Be Upon Him, gives his descendants a special position in the study of Alid family branches.
The attribution of this shrine requires caution. Local tradition remembers Fatimah and Ruqayyah as daughters of al-Hasan al-Muthanna, but the available summary sources do not clearly preserve full details about their lives, journeys, deaths, or burial in this location. This entry therefore records the site as a respected local attributed shrine.
Umdat al-Talib is useful for understanding the major Hasani branches, while Maqatil al-Talibiyyin helps frame the wider Alid historical experience. These works, however, do not provide a complete history for every local shrine. They are used here for genealogical background, while the specific shrine attribution remains local tradition.
The presence of many sayyid shrines in Babylon and al-Musayib reflects the deep popular memory of the Ahl al-Bayt along the Euphrates routes and near Karbala. The shrine of Banat al-Hasan al-Muthanna should be understood within that sacred geography.
The devotional atmosphere of the shrine is connected with the women of the Ahl al-Bayt, family purity, modesty, patience, and reverence for the household. Visitors often come to such sites with prayers for children, family well-being, and renewed love for the Ahl al-Bayt.
The variation in names should also be noted. The appearance of names such as Fatimah, Ruqayyah, Khadra, and Saada indicates a layered local tradition. These names should not all be treated as equally established without further verification.
For visitors, the shrine is a place of attachment to the women of the Hasani household. For researchers, it shows how genealogical background, local shrine fame, and popular naming traditions must be studied separately.
This entry preserves the shrine’s reverence while keeping the attribution cautious. The aim is to protect the devotional identity without turning unverified details into absolute historical claims.
According to the shrine's local custodial tradition, two remains are associated with a single grave and the discovery of the burial is placed approximately two centuries ago. This account does not replace an early inscription or a contemporary burial document, so it is retained explicitly as local devotional memory. Administratively, the site is in Babil, in the rural Al-Muhannawiya area between Abu Gharaq and Saddat al-Hindiya, close to the Karbala boundary.
Journey: Al-Muhannawiya, Saddat al-Hindiya, Babil, and the local Hasani shrine tradition near the Karbala boundary
Books: Umdat al-Talib, al-Majdi fi Ansab al-Talibiyyin, Nasab Quraysh, and Maqatil al-Talibiyyin
Historical / Religious Importance
This shrine preserves a local Hasani memory in the devotional landscape of Babil, Saddat al-Hindiya, and Al-Muhannawiya. Its significance lies in connecting the name of al-Hasan al-Muthanna with the remembered women of the Ahl al-Bayt, Peace Be Upon Them.
Historically, the site requires cautious wording. Classical genealogical works clarify the broad Hasani branches, but they do not preserve every detail of this particular shrine with certainty.
For visitors, the shrine recalls patience, modesty, family dignity, and love for the Ahl al-Bayt. For researchers, it is an important example of how local devotion, genealogical background, and popular naming traditions must be distinguished.
References
عمدة الطالب في أنساب آل أبي طالب
أحمد بن علي ابن عنبة
فرع الحسن المثنى؛ الصفحات تختلف باختلاف الطبعات
Umdat al-Talib, al-Majdi, and Nasab Quraysh are retained for Hasani genealogical background only; they do not independently prove burial at Al-Muhannawiya. The al-Kafeel forum page records the local custodial account, the two-remains/single-grave tradition, approximate two-century discovery claim, and location, but it is a forum/local source rather than an early document. The al-Burhan PDF is a genuine modern devotional publication about another Banat al-Hasan shrine in Najaf; it is retained only because it also notes the existence of a northern-Hillah shrine attributed to Ruqayyah and Fatimah. Exact identity and burial remain Under Review. | Page/Volume: السياق العام لأخبار الطالبيين؛ لا يثبت هذا المدفن بعينه | Umdat al-Talib, al-Majdi, and Nasab Quraysh are retained for Hasani genealogical background only; they do not independently prove burial at Al-Muhannawiya. The al-Kafeel forum page records the local custodial account, the two-remains/single-grave tradition, approximate two-century discovery claim, and location, but it is a forum/local source rather than an early document. The al-Burhan PDF is a genuine modern devotional publication about another Banat al-Hasan shrine in Najaf; it is retained only because it also notes the existence of a northern-Hillah shrine attributed to Ruqayyah and Fatimah. Exact identity and burial remain Under Review.
المجدي في أنساب الطالبيين
علي بن محمد العمري
أولاد الحسن المثنى؛ الصفحات تختلف باختلاف الطبعات
Umdat al-Talib, al-Majdi, and Nasab Quraysh are retained for Hasani genealogical background only; they do not independently prove burial at Al-Muhannawiya. The al-Kafeel forum page records the local custodial account, the two-remains/single-grave tradition, approximate two-century discovery claim, and location, but it is a forum/local source rather than an early document. The al-Burhan PDF is a genuine modern devotional publication about another Banat al-Hasan shrine in Najaf; it is retained only because it also notes the existence of a northern-Hillah shrine attributed to Ruqayyah and Fatimah. Exact identity and burial remain Under Review. | Page/Volume: السياق العام لأخبار الطالبيين؛ لا يثبت هذا المدفن بعينه | Umdat al-Talib, al-Majdi, and Nasab Quraysh are retained for Hasani genealogical background only; they do not independently prove burial at Al-Muhannawiya. The al-Kafeel forum page records the local custodial account, the two-remains/single-grave tradition, approximate two-century discovery claim, and location, but it is a forum/local source rather than an early document. The al-Burhan PDF is a genuine modern devotional publication about another Banat al-Hasan shrine in Najaf; it is retained only because it also notes the existence of a northern-Hillah shrine attributed to Ruqayyah and Fatimah. Exact identity and burial remain Under Review.
نسب قريش
مصعب بن عبد الله الزبيري
بنو الحسن بن علي؛ الصفحات تختلف باختلاف الطبعات
Umdat al-Talib, al-Majdi, and Nasab Quraysh are retained for Hasani genealogical background only; they do not independently prove burial at Al-Muhannawiya. The al-Kafeel forum page records the local custodial account, the two-remains/single-grave tradition, approximate two-century discovery claim, and location, but it is a forum/local source rather than an early document. The al-Burhan PDF is a genuine modern devotional publication about another Banat al-Hasan shrine in Najaf; it is retained only because it also notes the existence of a northern-Hillah shrine attributed to Ruqayyah and Fatimah. Exact identity and burial remain Under Review. | Page/Volume: السياق العام لأخبار الطالبيين؛ لا يثبت هذا المدفن بعينه | Umdat al-Talib, al-Majdi, and Nasab Quraysh are retained for Hasani genealogical background only; they do not independently prove burial at Al-Muhannawiya. The al-Kafeel forum page records the local custodial account, the two-remains/single-grave tradition, approximate two-century discovery claim, and location, but it is a forum/local source rather than an early document. The al-Burhan PDF is a genuine modern devotional publication about another Banat al-Hasan shrine in Najaf; it is retained only because it also notes the existence of a northern-Hillah shrine attributed to Ruqayyah and Fatimah. Exact identity and burial remain Under Review.
مقاتل الطالبيين
أبو الفرج الأصفهاني
السياق العام لأخبار الطالبيين؛ لا يثبت هذا المدفن
Umdat al-Talib, al-Majdi, and Nasab Quraysh are retained for Hasani genealogical background only; they do not independently prove burial at Al-Muhannawiya. The al-Kafeel forum page records the local custodial account, the two-remains/single-grave tradition, approximate two-century discovery claim, and location, but it is a forum/local source rather than an early document. The al-Burhan PDF is a genuine modern devotional publication about another Banat al-Hasan shrine in Najaf; it is retained only because it also notes the existence of a northern-Hillah shrine attributed to Ruqayyah and Fatimah. Exact identity and burial remain Under Review. | Page/Volume: السياق العام لأخبار الطالبيين؛ لا يثبت هذا المدفن بعينه | Umdat al-Talib, al-Majdi, and Nasab Quraysh are retained for Hasani genealogical background only; they do not independently prove burial at Al-Muhannawiya. The al-Kafeel forum page records the local custodial account, the two-remains/single-grave tradition, approximate two-century discovery claim, and location, but it is a forum/local source rather than an early document. The al-Burhan PDF is a genuine modern devotional publication about another Banat al-Hasan shrine in Najaf; it is retained only because it also notes the existence of a northern-Hillah shrine attributed to Ruqayyah and Fatimah. Exact identity and burial remain Under Review.
forums.alkafeel.net
Umdat al-Talib, al-Majdi, and Nasab Quraysh are retained for Hasani genealogical background only; they do not independently prove burial at Al-Muhannawiya. The al-Kafeel forum page records the local custodial account, the two-remains/single-grave tradition, approximate two-century discovery claim, and location, but it is a forum/local source rather than an early document. The al-Burhan PDF is a genuine modern devotional publication about another Banat al-Hasan shrine in Najaf; it is retained only because it also notes the existence of a northern-Hillah shrine attributed to Ruqayyah and Fatimah. Exact identity and burial remain Under Review. | Page/Volume: السياق العام لأخبار الطالبيين؛ لا يثبت هذا المدفن بعينه | Umdat al-Talib, al-Majdi, and Nasab Quraysh are retained for Hasani genealogical background only; they do not independently prove burial at Al-Muhannawiya. The al-Kafeel forum page records the local custodial account, the two-remains/single-grave tradition, approximate two-century discovery claim, and location, but it is a forum/local source rather than an early document. The al-Burhan PDF is a genuine modern devotional publication about another Banat al-Hasan shrine in Najaf; it is retained only because it also notes the existence of a northern-Hillah shrine attributed to Ruqayyah and Fatimah. Exact identity and burial remain Under Review.
www.alburhangroup.com
Umdat al-Talib, al-Majdi, and Nasab Quraysh are retained for Hasani genealogical background only; they do not independently prove burial at Al-Muhannawiya. The al-Kafeel forum page records the local custodial account, the two-remains/single-grave tradition, approximate two-century discovery claim, and location, but it is a forum/local source rather than an early document. The al-Burhan PDF is a genuine modern devotional publication about another Banat al-Hasan shrine in Najaf; it is retained only because it also notes the existence of a northern-Hillah shrine attributed to Ruqayyah and Fatimah. Exact identity and burial remain Under Review. | Page/Volume: السياق العام لأخبار الطالبيين؛ لا يثبت هذا المدفن بعينه | Umdat al-Talib, al-Majdi, and Nasab Quraysh are retained for Hasani genealogical background only; they do not independently prove burial at Al-Muhannawiya. The al-Kafeel forum page records the local custodial account, the two-remains/single-grave tradition, approximate two-century discovery claim, and location, but it is a forum/local source rather than an early document. The al-Burhan PDF is a genuine modern devotional publication about another Banat al-Hasan shrine in Najaf; it is retained only because it also notes the existence of a northern-Hillah shrine attributed to Ruqayyah and Fatimah. Exact identity and burial remain Under Review.