Tomb of Bahlool Dana, May Allah Have Mercy On Him
اردو العربية English فارسی हिन्दी
Bahlool al-Kufi; Wahb ibn Amr; Bahlool al-Majnun
What these badges mean
Badges are generated cautiously from the attached references, attribution notes, and GPS metadata. They are not a final historical ruling.
⚙️ Print, share, and more tools
Introduction
The present shrine of Bahlool Dana, May Allah Have Mercy On Him, stands in the old Karkh cemetery area associated with Al-Shuniziyya and Bab al-Dayr in Baghdad. It is the main website record for Bahlool and a long-established traditional attributed grave. The early biographical and literary books, however, describe Bahlool chiefly as a man of Kufa and do not identify this Baghdad structure as his burial place. The physical attribution therefore rests on later Baghdadi ziyarat, inscription and heritage memory, while the historical personality is established independently from earlier sources.
The strongest biographical form of his name is Abu Wahb Bahlool ibn Amr al-Sayrafi al-Kufi; Uqala al-Majanin also heads his section as Abu Wahb Bahlool ibn Amr ibn al-Mughira. Al-Wafi bil-Wafayat, volume 10, page 194, calls him a man of Kufa who narrated from Ayman ibn Nabil, Amr ibn Dinar and Asim ibn Abi al-Najud. Fawat al-Wafayat, volume 1, page 228, remembers him among the “wise madmen,” with attractive sayings, anecdotes and poetry. The later title Dana means wise or learned in Persian and belongs especially to the later Iraqi and Persianate memory of the figure.
An early literary witness is al-Jahiz, who writes in al-Bayan wa al-Tabyin, volume 2, page 159, that Bahlool was among the madmen of Kufa and “was inclined to Shiism.” This explicit early classification supports recording his historical affiliation, while it does not by itself verify every later Imami story attached to him. The biographical works agree more securely that he lived in the Abbasid period, was associated with Kufa, used striking humour and poetry, and was remembered as a man whose apparent eccentricity allowed serious moral criticism.
Uqala al-Majanin, pages 139–143 in the accessible edition, preserves the richest early collection of his reports. One account finds him in a cemetery with his legs hanging into a grave. When asked why he sat there, he replied that he was among people who did not harm him and did not backbite him in his absence. When told that food prices had risen and asked to pray for relief, he answered that people were responsible for worshipping Allah as commanded and that Allah had promised their provision. The scene links awareness of death with trust in divine provision and freedom from social injury.
The same book, pages 139–140, places a famous encounter outside Kufa when Harun al-Rashid was travelling for Hajj. Bahlool approached on a reed as children followed him. Asked to advise the caliph, he pointed to the palaces of former rulers and their graves, then said that whoever received beauty and wealth, remained chaste in beauty and generous with wealth, would be written among the righteous. When Harun offered to settle his debt or grant him a stipend, Bahlool refused, telling him not to pay one debt by creating another and saying that the One who provided for the caliph would not forget him.
Another form of the Harun encounter, preserved in Uqala al-Majanin and Sifat al-Safwa, connects political authority with the humility of pilgrimage. Bahlool narrated a report describing the Prophet Muhammad, Peace and Blessings Be Upon Him, performing Hajj without the harsh pushing and royal display that surrounded rulers. He reminded Harun that even if a person possessed the whole earth, the final destination would still be dust. In a related admonition he asked the ruler to return rights and gifts to their owners before seeking private absolution. The message is not merely comic resistance; it is a demand that leadership answer for wealth, ceremony and the rights of people.
Uqala al-Majanin, page 141, also preserves smaller incidents that reveal his ethical method. Asked what was most fitting for a person, he answered: righteous action. When someone requested his prayer and later offered him bread or payment after the need was fulfilled, Bahlool accepted ordinary food but refused to take a wage for prayer. The report places worship and supplication outside commercial bargaining and presents moral action as more important than clever speech.
The same collection, pages 142–143, records that children threw stones at him until one stone drew blood. Bahlool responded with poetry about trusting Allah and then expressed compassion for the children, hoping that Allah might set his pain against their joy and pardon one group through the other. Another poem warns that a person will soon travel to people whose speech is silence, meaning the inhabitants of the graves. These reports preserve the combination of humour, endurance, tenderness and remembrance of death that shaped his literary personality.
Later Imami works add a political explanation for his outward madness. Ayan al-Shia, volume 3, pages 617–623, preserves traditions that connect him with Imam Musa al-Kazim, Peace Be Upon Him, and say that he adopted the appearance of madness to escape an unjust judicial or political demand. The same work acknowledges uncertainty in some of the later sources from which these details were drawn. The article therefore retains this as an influential devotional and political tradition, while the earlier evidence establishes only the Kufa figure, his Shi‘i inclination and his moral speech—not every detailed scene of the concealment story.
A popular later devotional account, preserved in the collection Stories of Bahlool under “Bahlool Sells Paradise,” tells that Zubaydah gave him one hundred dinars for a garden of Paradise. Bahlool distributed the money among the poor. That night she dreamed of a magnificent garden and received a receipt written in gold. After hearing the dream, Harun offered the same amount, but Bahlool refused, explaining that Zubaydah had given before seeing the reward, whereas Harun acted only after hearing of it. This is a later ethical story rather than an early biographical report, but its complete meaning—charity, trust in the unseen and sincerity before reward—has been preserved.
The date of death also requires honest distinction. Al-Wafi bil-Wafayat and Fawat al-Wafayat place his death around 190 AH, while Ibn Kathir includes Bahlool al-Majnun among the deaths associated with 192 AH and says that he frequented the cemeteries of Kufa and advised Harun and others. These sources establish his Kufa setting more firmly than the location of his grave. No body-transfer narrative is used to bridge Kufa and Baghdad. The difference between approximately 190 and 192 AH is retained rather than replaced by a false exact date.
The Baghdad grave has a substantial later history of its own. A recent historical study of the site traces its earliest presently identified description to Hamd Allah Mustawfi, who saw a grave attributed to Bahlool in Baghdad during a visit in 1340 CE. Later European travellers, including Carsten Niebuhr and Louis Massignon, described the small dome, inscription and local title Bahlool Dana; Dana means wise in Persian. Modern Iraqi heritage writing continues to list Bahlool among figures remembered in the old Karkh cemetery landscape. The shrine is therefore valuable as a record of long Baghdadi devotional memory, while the article keeps the early Kufa biography, the later manaqib and the physical burial attribution at their proper evidentiary levels.
👨👦 Father's Side
🗺 Journey Timeline
📚 Books
Historical / Religious Importance
Bahlool's first historical importance lies in the ethical literature of Abbasid Kufa. Uqala al-Majanin, al-Wafi bil-Wafayat, Fawat al-Wafayat and al-Bayan wa al-Tabyin preserve a recognizable person whose humour, poetry and apparent eccentricity carried criticism of greed, power, backbiting and forgetfulness of death.
His reports about Harun al-Rashid gave later readers a language for speaking truth to rulers. The palace-and-grave contrast, refusal of royal money, humble Hajj report and demand to restore rights show that the centre of his wisdom was accountability before Allah and protection of people's rights, not entertainment at court.
The later Imami concealment tradition and the Paradise story demonstrate how his memory expanded across different devotional communities. By naming the early books, later sectarian compilations and modern story collections separately, the article preserves the moral value of these narratives without giving every layer the same historical authority.
The Baghdad shrine is important as a later urban and devotional monument. Its documentation by medieval and modern travellers shows a long history of local visitation, even though the early biography is more securely Kufan. The site therefore connects literary history, religious memory and the changing cemetery geography of Karkh while retaining the necessary distinction between person verification and burial verification.
📝 12 paragraphs · ~1145 words · 👨👦 1 father side · 🗺 6 Journey stages · 📚 7 Books
References
Primary source — عقلاء المجانين High
Notes: Page/Volume: ص 139–143 في الطبعة المصورة: الهوية، المقبرة، الثقة بالرزق، لقاءات الرشيد، الدعاء، الصبيان والأشعار | Article role: PRIMARY WEBSITE BIOGRAPHICAL RECORD / TRADITIONAL ATTRIBUTED BURIAL. The historical personality and physical grave are deliberately separated. Uqala al-Majanin, pp. 139–143, supports the cemetery scene, trust in provision, Harun encounters, righteous-action answer, refusal of payment for prayer, compassion toward children and death poetry. Al-Wafi bil-Wafayat, vol. 10, p. 194, and Fawat al-Wafayat, vol. 1, p. 228, support the Kufa identity, Abu Wahb Bahlool ibn Amr al-Sayrafi, transmitters, literary profile and death around 190 AH. Al-Bayan wa al-Tabyin, vol. 2, p. 159, is an early explicit source for his Shi'i inclination; is_shia was therefore corrected from No to Yes under the strict classification rule. Sifat al-Safwa corroborates the cemetery and Harun material. Ibn Kathir places him under deaths associated with 192 AH and describes his Kufa cemetery setting. Ayan al-Shia is used only for later Imami traditions and records its own caution about some of the underlying sources. The Paradise story is retained as a later devotional ethical story from the named modern compilation, not as an early biographical report. Early sources do not identify the current Baghdad structure as his burial place and no body-transfer story was invented. Later site documentation—Hamd Allah Mustawfi's reported 1340 visit and descriptions by Niebuhr and Massignon—supports a long Baghdadi attributed-grave tradition. The former generic al-Tabaqat al-Kubra reference was removed because it was not needed to support the final claims.
Primary source — الوافي بالوفيات High
Notes: Page/Volume: ج 10، ص 194: أبو وهيب بهلول بن عمرو الصيرفي الكوفي، شيوخه، وحدود الوفاة نحو 190هـ | Article role: PRIMARY WEBSITE BIOGRAPHICAL RECORD / TRADITIONAL ATTRIBUTED BURIAL. The historical personality and physical grave are deliberately separated. Uqala al-Majanin, pp. 139–143, supports the cemetery scene, trust in provision, Harun encounters, righteous-action answer, refusal of payment for prayer, compassion toward children and death poetry. Al-Wafi bil-Wafayat, vol. 10, p. 194, and Fawat al-Wafayat, vol. 1, p. 228, support the Kufa identity, Abu Wahb Bahlool ibn Amr al-Sayrafi, transmitters, literary profile and death around 190 AH. Al-Bayan wa al-Tabyin, vol. 2, p. 159, is an early explicit source for his Shi'i inclination; is_shia was therefore corrected from No to Yes under the strict classification rule. Sifat al-Safwa corroborates the cemetery and Harun material. Ibn Kathir places him under deaths associated with 192 AH and describes his Kufa cemetery setting. Ayan al-Shia is used only for later Imami traditions and records its own caution about some of the underlying sources. The Paradise story is retained as a later devotional ethical story from the named modern compilation, not as an early biographical report. Early sources do not identify the current Baghdad structure as his burial place and no body-transfer story was invented. Later site documentation—Hamd Allah Mustawfi's reported 1340 visit and descriptions by Niebuhr and Massignon—supports a long Baghdadi attributed-grave tradition. The former generic al-Tabaqat al-Kubra reference was removed because it was not needed to support the final claims.
Primary source — فوات الوفيات High
Notes: Page/Volume: ج 1، ص 228، ترجمة 84: الهوية الكوفية، عقلاء المجانين، النوادر والأشعار، والوفاة نحو 190هـ | Article role: PRIMARY WEBSITE BIOGRAPHICAL RECORD / TRADITIONAL ATTRIBUTED BURIAL. The historical personality and physical grave are deliberately separated. Uqala al-Majanin, pp. 139–143, supports the cemetery scene, trust in provision, Harun encounters, righteous-action answer, refusal of payment for prayer, compassion toward children and death poetry. Al-Wafi bil-Wafayat, vol. 10, p. 194, and Fawat al-Wafayat, vol. 1, p. 228, support the Kufa identity, Abu Wahb Bahlool ibn Amr al-Sayrafi, transmitters, literary profile and death around 190 AH. Al-Bayan wa al-Tabyin, vol. 2, p. 159, is an early explicit source for his Shi'i inclination; is_shia was therefore corrected from No to Yes under the strict classification rule. Sifat al-Safwa corroborates the cemetery and Harun material. Ibn Kathir places him under deaths associated with 192 AH and describes his Kufa cemetery setting. Ayan al-Shia is used only for later Imami traditions and records its own caution about some of the underlying sources. The Paradise story is retained as a later devotional ethical story from the named modern compilation, not as an early biographical report. Early sources do not identify the current Baghdad structure as his burial place and no body-transfer story was invented. Later site documentation—Hamd Allah Mustawfi's reported 1340 visit and descriptions by Niebuhr and Massignon—supports a long Baghdadi attributed-grave tradition. The former generic al-Tabaqat al-Kubra reference was removed because it was not needed to support the final claims.
Primary source — البيان والتبيين High
Notes: Page/Volume: ج 2، ص 159: ذكره بين مجانين الكوفة والتصريح بأنه كان يتشيع | Article role: PRIMARY WEBSITE BIOGRAPHICAL RECORD / TRADITIONAL ATTRIBUTED BURIAL. The historical personality and physical grave are deliberately separated. Uqala al-Majanin, pp. 139–143, supports the cemetery scene, trust in provision, Harun encounters, righteous-action answer, refusal of payment for prayer, compassion toward children and death poetry. Al-Wafi bil-Wafayat, vol. 10, p. 194, and Fawat al-Wafayat, vol. 1, p. 228, support the Kufa identity, Abu Wahb Bahlool ibn Amr al-Sayrafi, transmitters, literary profile and death around 190 AH. Al-Bayan wa al-Tabyin, vol. 2, p. 159, is an early explicit source for his Shi'i inclination; is_shia was therefore corrected from No to Yes under the strict classification rule. Sifat al-Safwa corroborates the cemetery and Harun material. Ibn Kathir places him under deaths associated with 192 AH and describes his Kufa cemetery setting. Ayan al-Shia is used only for later Imami traditions and records its own caution about some of the underlying sources. The Paradise story is retained as a later devotional ethical story from the named modern compilation, not as an early biographical report. Early sources do not identify the current Baghdad structure as his burial place and no body-transfer story was invented. Later site documentation—Hamd Allah Mustawfi's reported 1340 visit and descriptions by Niebuhr and Massignon—supports a long Baghdadi attributed-grave tradition. The former generic al-Tabaqat al-Kubra reference was removed because it was not needed to support the final claims.
Primary source — صفة الصفوة High
Notes: Page/Volume: ج 1، ص 516–518 في الطبعة المصورة: المقبرة ولقاء الرشيد وموعظة الحج؛ يختلف الترقيم الرقمي باختلاف النسخة | Article role: PRIMARY WEBSITE BIOGRAPHICAL RECORD / TRADITIONAL ATTRIBUTED BURIAL. The historical personality and physical grave are deliberately separated. Uqala al-Majanin, pp. 139–143, supports the cemetery scene, trust in provision, Harun encounters, righteous-action answer, refusal of payment for prayer, compassion toward children and death poetry. Al-Wafi bil-Wafayat, vol. 10, p. 194, and Fawat al-Wafayat, vol. 1, p. 228, support the Kufa identity, Abu Wahb Bahlool ibn Amr al-Sayrafi, transmitters, literary profile and death around 190 AH. Al-Bayan wa al-Tabyin, vol. 2, p. 159, is an early explicit source for his Shi'i inclination; is_shia was therefore corrected from No to Yes under the strict classification rule. Sifat al-Safwa corroborates the cemetery and Harun material. Ibn Kathir places him under deaths associated with 192 AH and describes his Kufa cemetery setting. Ayan al-Shia is used only for later Imami traditions and records its own caution about some of the underlying sources. The Paradise story is retained as a later devotional ethical story from the named modern compilation, not as an early biographical report. Early sources do not identify the current Baghdad structure as his burial place and no body-transfer story was invented. Later site documentation—Hamd Allah Mustawfi's reported 1340 visit and descriptions by Niebuhr and Massignon—supports a long Baghdadi attributed-grave tradition. The former generic al-Tabaqat al-Kubra reference was removed because it was not needed to support the final claims.
Secondary source — البداية والنهاية Medium
Notes: Page/Volume: ج 10، ضمن وفيات سنة 192هـ: بهلول المجنون ومقابر الكوفة ومواعظه؛ يختلف رقم الصفحة باختلاف الطبعة | Article role: PRIMARY WEBSITE BIOGRAPHICAL RECORD / TRADITIONAL ATTRIBUTED BURIAL. The historical personality and physical grave are deliberately separated. Uqala al-Majanin, pp. 139–143, supports the cemetery scene, trust in provision, Harun encounters, righteous-action answer, refusal of payment for prayer, compassion toward children and death poetry. Al-Wafi bil-Wafayat, vol. 10, p. 194, and Fawat al-Wafayat, vol. 1, p. 228, support the Kufa identity, Abu Wahb Bahlool ibn Amr al-Sayrafi, transmitters, literary profile and death around 190 AH. Al-Bayan wa al-Tabyin, vol. 2, p. 159, is an early explicit source for his Shi'i inclination; is_shia was therefore corrected from No to Yes under the strict classification rule. Sifat al-Safwa corroborates the cemetery and Harun material. Ibn Kathir places him under deaths associated with 192 AH and describes his Kufa cemetery setting. Ayan al-Shia is used only for later Imami traditions and records its own caution about some of the underlying sources. The Paradise story is retained as a later devotional ethical story from the named modern compilation, not as an early biographical report. Early sources do not identify the current Baghdad structure as his burial place and no body-transfer story was invented. Later site documentation—Hamd Allah Mustawfi's reported 1340 visit and descriptions by Niebuhr and Massignon—supports a long Baghdadi attributed-grave tradition. The former generic al-Tabaqat al-Kubra reference was removed because it was not needed to support the final claims.
Secondary source — أعيان الشيعة Medium
Notes: Page/Volume: ج 3، ص 617–623: صيغ الاسم، الروايات الإمامية المتأخرة، وصلته المنقولة بالإمام موسى الكاظم، والتنبيه على ضعف بعض المصادر | Article role: PRIMARY WEBSITE BIOGRAPHICAL RECORD / TRADITIONAL ATTRIBUTED BURIAL. The historical personality and physical grave are deliberately separated. Uqala al-Majanin, pp. 139–143, supports the cemetery scene, trust in provision, Harun encounters, righteous-action answer, refusal of payment for prayer, compassion toward children and death poetry. Al-Wafi bil-Wafayat, vol. 10, p. 194, and Fawat al-Wafayat, vol. 1, p. 228, support the Kufa identity, Abu Wahb Bahlool ibn Amr al-Sayrafi, transmitters, literary profile and death around 190 AH. Al-Bayan wa al-Tabyin, vol. 2, p. 159, is an early explicit source for his Shi'i inclination; is_shia was therefore corrected from No to Yes under the strict classification rule. Sifat al-Safwa corroborates the cemetery and Harun material. Ibn Kathir places him under deaths associated with 192 AH and describes his Kufa cemetery setting. Ayan al-Shia is used only for later Imami traditions and records its own caution about some of the underlying sources. The Paradise story is retained as a later devotional ethical story from the named modern compilation, not as an early biographical report. Early sources do not identify the current Baghdad structure as his burial place and no body-transfer story was invented. Later site documentation—Hamd Allah Mustawfi's reported 1340 visit and descriptions by Niebuhr and Massignon—supports a long Baghdadi attributed-grave tradition. The former generic al-Tabaqat al-Kubra reference was removed because it was not needed to support the final claims.
Secondary source — تاريخ الإسلام ووفيات المشاهير والأعلام Medium
Notes: Page/Volume: ترجمة بهلول بن عمرو أبي وهيب الصيرفي الكوفي: الرواة، وصفه من عقلاء المجانين، وحياته في دولة الرشيد؛ يختلف الترقيم باختلاف الطبعة | Article role: PRIMARY WEBSITE BIOGRAPHICAL RECORD / TRADITIONAL ATTRIBUTED BURIAL. The historical personality and physical grave are deliberately separated. Uqala al-Majanin, pp. 139–143, supports the cemetery scene, trust in provision, Harun encounters, righteous-action answer, refusal of payment for prayer, compassion toward children and death poetry. Al-Wafi bil-Wafayat, vol. 10, p. 194, and Fawat al-Wafayat, vol. 1, p. 228, support the Kufa identity, Abu Wahb Bahlool ibn Amr al-Sayrafi, transmitters, literary profile and death around 190 AH. Al-Bayan wa al-Tabyin, vol. 2, p. 159, is an early explicit source for his Shi'i inclination; is_shia was therefore corrected from No to Yes under the strict classification rule. Sifat al-Safwa corroborates the cemetery and Harun material. Ibn Kathir places him under deaths associated with 192 AH and describes his Kufa cemetery setting. Ayan al-Shia is used only for later Imami traditions and records its own caution about some of the underlying sources. The Paradise story is retained as a later devotional ethical story from the named modern compilation, not as an early biographical report. Early sources do not identify the current Baghdad structure as his burial place and no body-transfer story was invented. Later site documentation—Hamd Allah Mustawfi's reported 1340 visit and descriptions by Niebuhr and Massignon—supports a long Baghdadi attributed-grave tradition. The former generic al-Tabaqat al-Kubra reference was removed because it was not needed to support the final claims.
Website source — archive.org Medium
Notes: Article role: PRIMARY WEBSITE BIOGRAPHICAL RECORD / TRADITIONAL ATTRIBUTED BURIAL. The historical personality and physical grave are deliberately separated. Uqala al-Majanin, pp. 139–143, supports the cemetery scene, trust in provision, Harun encounters, righteous-action answer, refusal of payment for prayer, compassion toward children and death poetry. Al-Wafi bil-Wafayat, vol. 10, p. 194, and Fawat al-Wafayat, vol. 1, p. 228, support the Kufa identity, Abu Wahb Bahlool ibn Amr al-Sayrafi, transmitters, literary profile and death around 190 AH. Al-Bayan wa al-Tabyin, vol. 2, p. 159, is an early explicit source for his Shi'i inclination; is_shia was therefore corrected from No to Yes under the strict classification rule. Sifat al-Safwa corroborates the cemetery and Harun material. Ibn Kathir places him under deaths associated with 192 AH and describes his Kufa cemetery setting. Ayan al-Shia is used only for later Imami traditions and records its own caution about some of the underlying sources. The Paradise story is retained as a later devotional ethical story from the named modern compilation, not as an early biographical report. Early sources do not identify the current Baghdad structure as his burial place and no body-transfer story was invented. Later site documentation—Hamd Allah Mustawfi's reported 1340 visit and descriptions by Niebuhr and Massignon—supports a long Baghdadi attributed-grave tradition. The former generic al-Tabaqat al-Kubra reference was removed because it was not needed to support the final claims.
Website source — ablibrary.net Medium
Notes: Article role: PRIMARY WEBSITE BIOGRAPHICAL RECORD / TRADITIONAL ATTRIBUTED BURIAL. The historical personality and physical grave are deliberately separated. Uqala al-Majanin, pp. 139–143, supports the cemetery scene, trust in provision, Harun encounters, righteous-action answer, refusal of payment for prayer, compassion toward children and death poetry. Al-Wafi bil-Wafayat, vol. 10, p. 194, and Fawat al-Wafayat, vol. 1, p. 228, support the Kufa identity, Abu Wahb Bahlool ibn Amr al-Sayrafi, transmitters, literary profile and death around 190 AH. Al-Bayan wa al-Tabyin, vol. 2, p. 159, is an early explicit source for his Shi'i inclination; is_shia was therefore corrected from No to Yes under the strict classification rule. Sifat al-Safwa corroborates the cemetery and Harun material. Ibn Kathir places him under deaths associated with 192 AH and describes his Kufa cemetery setting. Ayan al-Shia is used only for later Imami traditions and records its own caution about some of the underlying sources. The Paradise story is retained as a later devotional ethical story from the named modern compilation, not as an early biographical report. Early sources do not identify the current Baghdad structure as his burial place and no body-transfer story was invented. Later site documentation—Hamd Allah Mustawfi's reported 1340 visit and descriptions by Niebuhr and Massignon—supports a long Baghdadi attributed-grave tradition. The former generic al-Tabaqat al-Kubra reference was removed because it was not needed to support the final claims.
Website source — shamela.ws Medium
Notes: Article role: PRIMARY WEBSITE BIOGRAPHICAL RECORD / TRADITIONAL ATTRIBUTED BURIAL. The historical personality and physical grave are deliberately separated. Uqala al-Majanin, pp. 139–143, supports the cemetery scene, trust in provision, Harun encounters, righteous-action answer, refusal of payment for prayer, compassion toward children and death poetry. Al-Wafi bil-Wafayat, vol. 10, p. 194, and Fawat al-Wafayat, vol. 1, p. 228, support the Kufa identity, Abu Wahb Bahlool ibn Amr al-Sayrafi, transmitters, literary profile and death around 190 AH. Al-Bayan wa al-Tabyin, vol. 2, p. 159, is an early explicit source for his Shi'i inclination; is_shia was therefore corrected from No to Yes under the strict classification rule. Sifat al-Safwa corroborates the cemetery and Harun material. Ibn Kathir places him under deaths associated with 192 AH and describes his Kufa cemetery setting. Ayan al-Shia is used only for later Imami traditions and records its own caution about some of the underlying sources. The Paradise story is retained as a later devotional ethical story from the named modern compilation, not as an early biographical report. Early sources do not identify the current Baghdad structure as his burial place and no body-transfer story was invented. Later site documentation—Hamd Allah Mustawfi's reported 1340 visit and descriptions by Niebuhr and Massignon—supports a long Baghdadi attributed-grave tradition. The former generic al-Tabaqat al-Kubra reference was removed because it was not needed to support the final claims.
Website source — shamela.ws Medium
Notes: Article role: PRIMARY WEBSITE BIOGRAPHICAL RECORD / TRADITIONAL ATTRIBUTED BURIAL. The historical personality and physical grave are deliberately separated. Uqala al-Majanin, pp. 139–143, supports the cemetery scene, trust in provision, Harun encounters, righteous-action answer, refusal of payment for prayer, compassion toward children and death poetry. Al-Wafi bil-Wafayat, vol. 10, p. 194, and Fawat al-Wafayat, vol. 1, p. 228, support the Kufa identity, Abu Wahb Bahlool ibn Amr al-Sayrafi, transmitters, literary profile and death around 190 AH. Al-Bayan wa al-Tabyin, vol. 2, p. 159, is an early explicit source for his Shi'i inclination; is_shia was therefore corrected from No to Yes under the strict classification rule. Sifat al-Safwa corroborates the cemetery and Harun material. Ibn Kathir places him under deaths associated with 192 AH and describes his Kufa cemetery setting. Ayan al-Shia is used only for later Imami traditions and records its own caution about some of the underlying sources. The Paradise story is retained as a later devotional ethical story from the named modern compilation, not as an early biographical report. Early sources do not identify the current Baghdad structure as his burial place and no body-transfer story was invented. Later site documentation—Hamd Allah Mustawfi's reported 1340 visit and descriptions by Niebuhr and Massignon—supports a long Baghdadi attributed-grave tradition. The former generic al-Tabaqat al-Kubra reference was removed because it was not needed to support the final claims.
Website source — lib.eshia.ir Medium
Notes: Article role: PRIMARY WEBSITE BIOGRAPHICAL RECORD / TRADITIONAL ATTRIBUTED BURIAL. The historical personality and physical grave are deliberately separated. Uqala al-Majanin, pp. 139–143, supports the cemetery scene, trust in provision, Harun encounters, righteous-action answer, refusal of payment for prayer, compassion toward children and death poetry. Al-Wafi bil-Wafayat, vol. 10, p. 194, and Fawat al-Wafayat, vol. 1, p. 228, support the Kufa identity, Abu Wahb Bahlool ibn Amr al-Sayrafi, transmitters, literary profile and death around 190 AH. Al-Bayan wa al-Tabyin, vol. 2, p. 159, is an early explicit source for his Shi'i inclination; is_shia was therefore corrected from No to Yes under the strict classification rule. Sifat al-Safwa corroborates the cemetery and Harun material. Ibn Kathir places him under deaths associated with 192 AH and describes his Kufa cemetery setting. Ayan al-Shia is used only for later Imami traditions and records its own caution about some of the underlying sources. The Paradise story is retained as a later devotional ethical story from the named modern compilation, not as an early biographical report. Early sources do not identify the current Baghdad structure as his burial place and no body-transfer story was invented. Later site documentation—Hamd Allah Mustawfi's reported 1340 visit and descriptions by Niebuhr and Massignon—supports a long Baghdadi attributed-grave tradition. The former generic al-Tabaqat al-Kubra reference was removed because it was not needed to support the final claims.
Website source — al-islam.org Medium
Notes: Article role: PRIMARY WEBSITE BIOGRAPHICAL RECORD / TRADITIONAL ATTRIBUTED BURIAL. The historical personality and physical grave are deliberately separated. Uqala al-Majanin, pp. 139–143, supports the cemetery scene, trust in provision, Harun encounters, righteous-action answer, refusal of payment for prayer, compassion toward children and death poetry. Al-Wafi bil-Wafayat, vol. 10, p. 194, and Fawat al-Wafayat, vol. 1, p. 228, support the Kufa identity, Abu Wahb Bahlool ibn Amr al-Sayrafi, transmitters, literary profile and death around 190 AH. Al-Bayan wa al-Tabyin, vol. 2, p. 159, is an early explicit source for his Shi'i inclination; is_shia was therefore corrected from No to Yes under the strict classification rule. Sifat al-Safwa corroborates the cemetery and Harun material. Ibn Kathir places him under deaths associated with 192 AH and describes his Kufa cemetery setting. Ayan al-Shia is used only for later Imami traditions and records its own caution about some of the underlying sources. The Paradise story is retained as a later devotional ethical story from the named modern compilation, not as an early biographical report. Early sources do not identify the current Baghdad structure as his burial place and no body-transfer story was invented. Later site documentation—Hamd Allah Mustawfi's reported 1340 visit and descriptions by Niebuhr and Massignon—supports a long Baghdadi attributed-grave tradition. The former generic al-Tabaqat al-Kubra reference was removed because it was not needed to support the final claims.
Gallery
📤 Submit a photo of this site
Nearby shrines
⏳ Loading nearby shrines…
Ibrahim al-Khawwas
0.02 km away
Maqam of Prophet Joshua bin Nun, Peace Be Upon Him
0.04 km away
Junayd of Baghdad
0.12 km away
Shaykh Abu al-Hasan Sari ibn al-Mughallis al-Saqati
0.12 km away
Maqam attributed to Dawud al-Ta'i, May Allah Have Mercy on Him
0.75 km away
Mausoleum of Zumurrud Khatun, May Allah Have Mercy on Her
0.99 km away
Maruf al-Karkhi
1.01 km away
Attributed Memorial of Husayn ibn Mansur al-Hallaj, May Allah Have Mercy On Him
1.32 km away
Maqam of Al-Khidr Elias, Peace Be Upon Him
1.58 km away
Habib al-Ajami
1.86 km away