Attributed Shrine of Banat al-Hasan, Peace Be Upon Them, in Al-Karmah, Anbar
اردو العربية English فارسی हिन्दी
Banat al-Hasan Al-Karmah; Banat al-Hasan Anbar; Tall Banat al-Hasan
What these badges mean
Badges are generated cautiously from the attached references, attribution notes, and GPS metadata. They are not a final historical ruling.
⚙️ Print, share, and more tools
Introduction
The shrine of Banat al-Hasan, Peace Be Upon Them, in al-Karmah, Anbar, belongs to the local devotional geography of western Iraq. It is known in local memory as Banat al-Hasan, Tall Banat al-Hasan, and the shrine of the daughters of Hasan. This entry treats it as an attributed local shrine rather than a fully documented historical burial site, preserving both respect and scholarly caution.
The wider Hasani lineage belongs to the descendants of Imam Hasan ibn Ali, Peace Be Upon Him. Classical genealogical works such as Umdat al-Talib help explain the major Hasani and Husayni branches, but the available classical material does not clearly preserve the names, number, father, mother, life period, or full chain of the women attached to this specific shrine in al-Karmah. For that reason, the wording remains limited to a general Hasani attribution and local shrine memory.
Two matters should be separated. First, the historical presence of Hasani descendants in Iraq is well known across many regions. Second, connecting a specific local shrine to particular named women requires stronger genealogical or historical evidence. The available material for this site is mainly local and modern, so the entry avoids presenting an unverified chain as established history.
In local usage, the name Banat al-Hasan appears as a collective title. It may refer to two or more women from a Hasani family, to a remembered household, or to a devotional name that became attached to a hill, a cemetery space, and a shrine area over time. Since the evidence is limited, no specific names or unsupported family tree have been inserted.
The al-Karmah and Anbar region is connected with routes between Baghdad, Fallujah, Karbala, and central Iraq. In such regions, many shrines preserve a mixture of local naming, tribal memory, family attribution, and devotional visitation. This shrine appears to belong to that category.
Modern summaries mention Tall Banat al-Hasan, the Banat al-Hasan district, Nahiya al-Khayrat, and nearby villages. These details support the modern existence and local identity of the shrine, but they do not replace classical genealogical proof. The website references are therefore used only for location and modern shrine identity.
For visitors, the shrine represents love for the Household of the Prophet, remembrance of the Hasani line, and the quiet devotional memory of local Iraq. It is a place where inherited naming and public visitation preserve a memory that may not be fully documented in early books.
For researchers, Banat al-Hasan in al-Karmah is a useful case of how local shrines should be read with respect and caution. The site should not be dismissed, because its local identity is known, but it should also not be described as a conclusively proven burial with a fixed lineage chain. The safest wording is: an attributed local shrine connected with the memory of Banat al-Hasan.
Historical / Religious Importance
This shrine matters in the devotional map of Anbar because it connects the Hasani memory of the Ahl al-Bayt with local public visitation. Although a conclusive historical chain is not preserved, the name, hill, shrine identity, and local visitation show how Iraqi sacred memory can survive through place and community.
For researchers, the site is important because it requires a clear distinction between classical genealogy and modern local tradition. Umdat al-Talib explains major Hasani branches, but it does not by itself prove the specific names or lineage of the women attached to this shrine.
For visitors, the shrine represents love for the Ahl al-Bayt, remembrance of Sayyid women, and the quiet religious memory of Anbar. The most balanced wording is to describe it as a local shrine attributed to Banat al-Hasan.
📝 8 paragraphs · ~464 words
References
Primary source — عمدة الطالب في أنساب آل أبي طالب High
Notes: Page/Volume: Hasani genealogical branches; pagination varies by edition | The genealogical books support only the general Hasani and Alid background; they do not identify the number, names, parents, or exact lineage of the women associated with this site. The modern geographic source supports the Banat al-Hasan area, hill, cemetery environment, Al-Khayrat Subdistrict, and Al-Karmah administrative setting. The present shrine identity is therefore preserved as local devotional memory, while burial and lineage remain unverified. | Page/Volume: Alid family and historical background; pagination varies by edition | The genealogical books support only the general Hasani and Alid background; they do not identify the number, names, parents, or exact lineage of the women associated with this site. The modern geographic source supports the Banat al-Hasan area, hill, cemetery environment, Al-Khayrat Subdistrict, and Al-Karmah administrative setting. The present shrine identity is therefore preserved as local devotional memory, while burial and lineage remain unverified. | The genealogical books support only the general Hasani and Alid background; they do not identify the number, names, parents, or exact lineage of the women associated with this site. The modern geographic source supports the Banat al-Hasan area, hill, cemetery environment, Al-Khayrat Subdistrict, and Al-Karmah administrative setting. The present shrine identity is therefore preserved as local devotional memory, while burial and lineage remain unverified.
Secondary source — مقاتل الطالبيين Medium
Notes: Page/Volume: Hasani genealogical branches; pagination varies by edition | The genealogical books support only the general Hasani and Alid background; they do not identify the number, names, parents, or exact lineage of the women associated with this site. The modern geographic source supports the Banat al-Hasan area, hill, cemetery environment, Al-Khayrat Subdistrict, and Al-Karmah administrative setting. The present shrine identity is therefore preserved as local devotional memory, while burial and lineage remain unverified. | Page/Volume: Alid family and historical background; pagination varies by edition | The genealogical books support only the general Hasani and Alid background; they do not identify the number, names, parents, or exact lineage of the women associated with this site. The modern geographic source supports the Banat al-Hasan area, hill, cemetery environment, Al-Khayrat Subdistrict, and Al-Karmah administrative setting. The present shrine identity is therefore preserved as local devotional memory, while burial and lineage remain unverified. | The genealogical books support only the general Hasani and Alid background; they do not identify the number, names, parents, or exact lineage of the women associated with this site. The modern geographic source supports the Banat al-Hasan area, hill, cemetery environment, Al-Khayrat Subdistrict, and Al-Karmah administrative setting. The present shrine identity is therefore preserved as local devotional memory, while burial and lineage remain unverified.
Website source — ar.wikipedia.org Medium
Notes: Page/Volume: Hasani genealogical branches; pagination varies by edition | The genealogical books support only the general Hasani and Alid background; they do not identify the number, names, parents, or exact lineage of the women associated with this site. The modern geographic source supports the Banat al-Hasan area, hill, cemetery environment, Al-Khayrat Subdistrict, and Al-Karmah administrative setting. The present shrine identity is therefore preserved as local devotional memory, while burial and lineage remain unverified. | Page/Volume: Alid family and historical background; pagination varies by edition | The genealogical books support only the general Hasani and Alid background; they do not identify the number, names, parents, or exact lineage of the women associated with this site. The modern geographic source supports the Banat al-Hasan area, hill, cemetery environment, Al-Khayrat Subdistrict, and Al-Karmah administrative setting. The present shrine identity is therefore preserved as local devotional memory, while burial and lineage remain unverified. | The genealogical books support only the general Hasani and Alid background; they do not identify the number, names, parents, or exact lineage of the women associated with this site. The modern geographic source supports the Banat al-Hasan area, hill, cemetery environment, Al-Khayrat Subdistrict, and Al-Karmah administrative setting. The present shrine identity is therefore preserved as local devotional memory, while burial and lineage remain unverified.
Gallery
📤 Submit a photo of this site
Nearby shrines
⏳ Loading nearby shrines…